Contractual Disputes in Light of Qatari Civil Code
Contractual disputes are among the most common cases brought before civil courts in Qatar. These disputes arise when parties disagree on the performance of a contractual obligation, whether due to delay or a breach of agreement. In such instances, Qatari Civil Code plays a fundamental role in determining the rights and obligations of the disputing parties. Many inquire about how contracts are interpreted, the extent to which the performance of obligations is mandatory, and how to address breaches or delays. Qatari law provides a comprehensive legal framework for resolving these disputes, ensuring the rights of the aggrieved party while defining the legal avenues for protection and compensation.
Example: If there is a contract between a construction company and a property owner to deliver a project within 6 months, and a delay occurs because the contractor failed to supply materials on time, a contractual dispute arises regarding the delayed performance and the owner’s right to claim compensation.
The Legal Basis for Resolving Contractual Disputes in Qatari Civil Code
Qatari Civil Code No. 22 of 2004 addresses the obligations of parties when a contractual dispute occurs and provides a set of articles to protect the aggrieved party:
- Article 171/1: The contract is binding upon the parties and may not be amended except by mutual agreement of the parties or by force of law.
- Article 256: Grants the right to compensation for damages resulting from the non-performance or delay of obligations, unless it is proven that such failure or delay was due to a foreign cause beyond the debtor’s control beyond the party’s control.
Read also: The flexibility of commercial contracts in the face of economic crises: legal solutions
Judicial Approach of the Court for Reviewing Contractual Disputes
The court follows organized steps to address and fairly resolve a contractual dispute:
- Verification of the Validity of the Contract: Confirming the presence of essential elements (Consent, Subject Matter, and Cause). If the contract is written and signed, the judge verifies the authenticity of signatures and the date of agreement.
- Determining Obligations: Determining the rights and obligations stipulated in the contract. If the contract requires a contractor to complete work within a specific timeframe, the court must verify if this condition was met.
- Examination of Breach or Delay: Determining if there was a failure to perform or a delay. For instance, if a contractor delivers the work a month late, a breach is established that the court must examine.
- Verification of Legal Justifications: Checking for any Force Majeure or “Foreign Cause” that led to non-performance. For example, if a natural disaster prevents execution, the defendant may present this as a legal excuse.
- Issuance of Final Judgment: The court may order specific performance, monetary compensation, or rescission with damages. If a breach is confirmed and specific performance is impossible, the judge may award monetary compensation to the aggrieved party.
Means of Protecting the Aggrieved Party in a Contractual Dispute
Specific Performance (Execution in Kind):
This involves demanding the debtor to fulfill their obligation exactly as agreed in the contract, such as delivering goods or performing a specific service.
Monetary Compensation for Damages:
The aggrieved party is awarded a financial sum to compensate for losses resulting from the delay or non-performance.
Judicial Rescission of the Contract:
In cases of fundamental breach, the aggrieved party may request the rescission (termination) of the contract along with a claim for damages, which aims to restore the parties to their pre-contractual positions.
Common Legal FAQs Regarding Contractual Disputes
Can a contract be amended by the will of only one party?
No. The contract is the law of the parties and cannot be amended except by mutual agreement or by force of law.
For example, if one party wishes to change the delivery date but the other objects, the contract cannot be modified.
Exceptions: A judge has the authority to amend a contract in cases of “Emergency Circumstances” (Force Majeure)
or “Gross Inequity” (Lesion) suffered by one of the contracting parties.
Read also: 5 effective legal strategies for debt collection in Qatar
What happens if a debtor delays the performance of their obligation?
This is considered a breach of contract. The aggrieved party has the right to demand compensation or specific performance, potentially alongside the imposition of delay penalties (liquidated damages).
Example: If a supplier fails to deliver products on the agreed date, the aggrieved party can claim damages for losses resulting from the delay.
Can a judge rescind the contract directly?
Yes, a judge may rescind the contract if the breach is fundamental (gross) to the extent that it renders performance impossible or futile for the other party.
Example: If a supply company fails to deliver the required materials and the delay persists for an excessively long period, the judge may order the rescission of the contract.
Conclusion: Balancing Justice and Obligation in Contractual Disputes
In resolving contractual disputes, Qatari Civil Code relies on the fundamental principle of (The contract is the law of the parties). It ensures a balance of justice by protecting the aggrieved party while granting the debtor the opportunity to prove a legal excuse for the breach. This balance contributes to the stability of commercial transactions and helps achieve equity between the parties.
